← Smart Home
C

Nest Hub (2nd Gen)

Notable issues
Google · 🇺🇸 United States · WiFi + Bluetooth
PolicyApp PermissionsNetwork TrafficFirmwareRegulatory
Technical details
App: Google Home
Manufacturer: Google

The bottom line

Google put a radar sensor in a bedside device that tracks your breathing, movement, coughing, and snoring all night. They said radar is more private than a camera. It is more intimate. A camera sees your face. The radar measures your respiratory rate and knows when you toss and turn. Google now has your sleep data alongside your search history. It knows what keeps you up at night — literally and figuratively. Google put a microphone in the original Nest Hub and forgot to mention it. Not in the specs. Not in the marketing. Not on the box. They called it a documentation error. A microphone in a bedroom device, accidentally undisclosed. Google paid $5.4 million to settle the lawsuit. The microphone is still there in every unit sold.

Legal jurisdiction
🇺🇸 United States (headquarters)
CLOUD Act read more →
US govt can demand your data from this company even if stored overseas
FISA §702 / PRISM read more →
NSA collects stored emails, photos, messages without individual warrants
Geofence warrants read more →
Police can demand location data for everyone near a crime scene
Spying
2/4 MODERATE
Is someone spying on me?
Data Sharing
1/4 LOW
Who gets my data?
Security
0/4 N/A
Is it actually secure?
Honesty
1/4 LOW
Can I trust what they say?
ACCEPTABLE Moderate concerns. Standard privacy hygiene applies.
2Contradictions
0Critical
2High
0Medium
2Sources
Findings by concern
Spying 2/4 MODERATE 1 finding
⚡ highprivacy policy vs regulatory
Google put a microphone in the original Nest Hub and forgot to mention it. Not in the specs. Not in the marketing. Not on the box. They called it a documentation error. A microphone in a bedroom device, accidentally undisclosed. Google paid $5.4 million to settle the lawsuit. The microphone is still there in every unit sold.

What they claim: Google describes Nest Hub data collection as optional and user-controlled

What we found: Google paid $5.4 million to settle a lawsuit over the original Nest Hub's undisclosed microphone. The device shipped with a microphone that was not mentioned in the product specifications or marketing materials. Google called it an "error" in the product documentation. A microphone hidden in a device that sits in your bedroom — accidentally undocumented.

Data Sharing 1/4 LOW 1 finding
⚡ highmarketing vs third party research
Google put a radar sensor in a bedside device that tracks your breathing, movement, coughing, and snoring all night. They said radar is more private than a camera. It is more intimate. A camera sees your face. The radar measures your respiratory rate and knows when you toss and turn. Google now has your sleep data alongside your search history. It knows what keeps you up at night — literally and figuratively.

What they claim: Google Nest Hub promotes sleep tracking via Soli radar as a privacy-friendly alternative to cameras

What we found: The Nest Hub's Soli radar tracks breathing rate, movement, coughing, and snoring throughout the night, creating a detailed physiological profile of your sleep. This health data is sent to Google's cloud and processed alongside your search history, YouTube watches, location history, and email. Google positioned radar as "more private than a camera" but the data collected is arguably more intimate.

What happened to real people
Documented incidents involving Google products and user data.
Jorge Molina jailed 6 days for murder via geofence warrant based on Google Sensorvault location data. Lost job, car, reputation. Charges never filed. [source]
PRISM participant since 2009. NSA collects stored communications. FBI conducts warrantless 'backdoor searches' of American data using names and email addresses. [source]
Google received 180 geofence warrants per week by 2019. Each warrant searches tens of millions of accounts. Supreme Court hearing constitutionality (Chatrie v. United States). [source]
What your data is worth to governments
Google complied with 235,000 government data requests in H1 2024. That's +530% over 10 years. Google has been a confirmed PRISM participant since 2009. Under this programme, the NSA collects stored communications. The company is legally prohibited from telling you. Jurisdiction: US (CLOUD Act, FISA Section 702, Patriot Act).
Documented: Jorge Molina jailed 6 days for murder via geofence warrant based on Google Sensorvault location data. Lost job, car, reputation. Charges never filed.
Documented: PRISM participant since 2009. NSA collects stored communications. FBI conducts warrantless 'backdoor searches' of American data using names and email addresses.
What is PRISM? · What is the CLOUD Act? · Transparency report
Sources